Account Manager (AM) vs. Account Executive (AE): Which do you prefer & why?

Here are some base assumptions:


ACCOUNT MANAGER

  • Also known as "Customer Success Manager," "Partner Manager," "Client Success Manager," etc.
  • Charged w/ upselling, growing, renewing existing accounts.
  • More of a "farmer" role.

Pros:

  • Generally considered less volatile than AE.
  • You get to develop deeper client relationships, perhaps more interesting than the repetitive nature of AE work.

Cons:

  • Can pay less than AE. AMs typically cap out at $200k OTE, whereas AEs can make $300-350k OTE. And with accelerators / over-performance, AEs can make $500k - $1M, whereas this is generally unattainable for an individual contributor (IC) AM.
  • You have to deal with more "baggage" than AEs. AEs can sign a very tough client & forget about it. The AMs are tasked with keeping them happy indefinitely and delivering on promises that AEs may have over-promised.

ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE

  • May also known as "Sales Executive," "Sales Director," etc.
  • Charged with closing net-new business / logos
  • More of a "hunter" role

Pros:

  • Compensation: As discussed earlier, with the right product / accounts / territory, you can smash into 7-figure upside.
  • Work is generally straightforward & strictly defined: you know exactly what you need to do; what success looks like is clear-cut. You generally don't have to put out a fire w/ the product on Christmas Eve as an Account Manager might have to. The scope of your engagement begins & ends with you hitting your performance KPIs and closing revenue. In short, you can essentially set your own schedule as long as you're hitting quota.

Cons:

  • Depending on what environment you're in, it's "do or die." It's a what-have-you-done-for-me-lately kind of job where you're only as good as your last 2 quarters. As time goes on, you may box your self in. If you sign too many accounts, what logos are there left to sign? As time goes on, your territory may get smaller, your vertical may get smaller. And if you CRUSH your quota this year, management may double it for the next year, building a bridge to nowhere. As such, shelf life for AEs may be short, perhaps 1.5 - 2.0 years in some places.

What are your thoughts on this analysis? And which side do you prefer & why?

Which job title do you prefer?

Attached poll
*Voting in this poll no longer yields commission.
๐ŸฅŽ Training
๐Ÿ’ฐ Compensation
13
Kosta_Konfucius
Politicker
7
Sales Rep
I prefer 100% farming over 100% hunting, but will take an AE role with sdr/inbound support over an AM
jefe
Arsonist
1
๐Ÿ
I definitely understand this..
oldcloser
Arsonist
6
๐Ÿ’€
Sunbunny31
Politicker
2
Sr Sales Executive ๐Ÿฐ
Better not be wabbit season.
Filth
Politicker
1
Live Filthy or Die Clean
AM comes with a lot of BS and support/implementation woes, AE is more hit it and forget it. I MISS IT SO BAD.
CuriousFox
WR Officer
2
๐ŸฆŠ
Hit and quit bay-bee
Filth
Politicker
1
Live Filthy or Die Clean
me-ow!
LambyCorn
Arsonist
0
A mfkn E
If I could choose. AE
pirate
Big Shot
0
๐Ÿฆœโ˜ ๏ธ Account Executive
My current role is more of AM but get paid on closing new customers and not renewing old ones. But generally AE
GDO
Politicker
1
BDM
This mix is the best. Build you book and upsell/renew
FoodForSales
Politicker
0
AE
AE
kittychachas
Valued Contributor
0
VP/Director of Sales
AE. The thrill is in the chase. Going after a whale or a key account, working through the complexity of the sale, and proving out our solution. Upwards of two years for some accounts but once that contract comes back signed itโ€™s a feeling that canโ€™t be beat.
SaasSlingin
Politicker
0
Sr AE
My new role is a hybrid one split between install base and net new. That said, I deal with a lot of bullshit and support with current customers leading me to chose AE here.
kneehigh
Politicker
0
Senior Enterprise AE
I have a mix - new account focus and I manage accounts I land to get upsell revenue. Iโ€™m doing E sales though and typically Iโ€™m doing 4-6 new clients a year at $250k+ a deal then there is upsell on top of this which I keep all commission too
11

CSM/Account Manager vs Account Executive

Discussion
17
9

Account Manager vs Account Executive

Question
18