The Finance Manager

Ah, the age of getting the CFO engaged in your sales cycle.


I've actually enjoyed it. Much of the value I add in the sales cycle is taking a lot of the work out of evaluating cost models on usage-based products. The CFO loves that.


Today, I got an inbound from a Finance Manager at a company I've long outbounded to. It seemed like the blue bird my tireless outbound efforts earned me. Karma.


Nope...trap.


Dude gave me great intel on what they needed now, the future value of what they wanted, metrics to price to...then the clear indication I would be a pawn in his renewal discussion with a competitor.


He has no issue with his incumbent, other than price.


He has quotes from competitors to negotiate the renewal.


His renewal discussion is tomorrow. His deadline is Friday.


His team in no case will make a commitment to a new vendor before Friday, but if the price is right and incumbent can't compete he simply doesn't renew.


cool...then let's talk next week when you don't renew with that vendor.


It's tough to say no to an eval today, but far too many times I've run a 911 to throw my name in and drive value along with price..only for someone not give a shit and use my model to get a lower price with their incumbent.


The point is, how do you know the Finance Manager isn't a crazy glue sniffer? "Building model airplanes" he says, but we're not buying it. Next thing you know, there's money missing off the dresser and your daughter's knocked up...seen it a hundred times.

๐Ÿฐ War Stories
โ˜๏ธ Software Tech
โ˜‘๏ธ Qualification Calls
8
oldcloser
Arsonist
4
๐Ÿ’€
Donโ€™t mean to laugh, but that close was classic. Sorry man. You could get nasty and give him price with an expiring clock. Then send that to the incumbent. Ask them for an โ€œaffiliate commissionโ€ when he renews. ๐Ÿคท๐Ÿปโ€โ™‚๏ธProbably not the best advice Iโ€™ve given.
ChickenWings
Opinionated
1
Tom Callahan's Son
haha bold

full of 90s movie quotes where i can apply them
Maximas
Tycoon
0
Senior Sales Executive
Wild one, lmao:)
CuriousFox
WR Officer
4
๐ŸฆŠ
You always have to be ok to walk away from a prospect. Otherwise they will own your ass.
Sunbunny31
Politicker
3
Sr Sales Executive ๐Ÿฐ
100%. It's ok to say no, and tell them why. That you appreciate them reaching out, but it does everyone a disservice for you to scramble to respond when the other vendors had (weeks? months?) to prepare.
ChickenWings
Opinionated
1
Tom Callahan's Son
Absolutely.

He actually responded well to my response saying, though we appreciate the opportunity we are simply too late in the renewal process to be a serious participant. That he should have what he needs for his decision this week. If he decides to not renew and find someone new, my door was open for next week.
Sunbunny31
Politicker
2
Sr Sales Executive ๐Ÿฐ
That's a great response.
punishedlad
Tycoon
2
Business Development Team Lead
Yeah this is ass and you should 100% walk away.

Maybe check in to see if they actually moved forward, but that sounds like an absolutely awful working relationship
Pachacuti
Politicker
3
They call me Daddy, Sales Daddy
fun being the tool in someone else's game. At least he was straight up with you on that. I'd give your odds of winning <1%.
ChickenWings
Opinionated
0
Tom Callahan's Son
True. He did help me say no.
detectivegibbles
Politicker
3
Sales Director
I don't think you ever KNOW...but trust your gut. It's usually right. Move onto someone who wants to work with you. They're out there.
HVACexpert
Politicker
2
sales engineer
Yeah itโ€™s always tough. Chances are small you get anything out of it. But chances are ZERO if you donโ€™t send anything either. Itโ€™s 100% a shitty game we have to play sometimes. You could play some game back at the guy but does that win the battle and lose the war? Is this someone you even want to do business with? Iโ€™ve been on both sides of the โ€˜checkโ€™ number and it sucks either way. Youโ€™re getting used to negotiating down someone else, or a job you know you have, you have to reduce price because they are the throwing someone elseโ€™s bullshit number in your face that probably doesnโ€™t have the same scope as you.

Gone through it a lot over the years, itโ€™s annoying every time.
ChickenWings
Opinionated
1
Tom Callahan's Son
Yup. Losing the battle to maybe win the war, here.

Cut early, no hard feelings.
poweredbycaffeine
WR Lieutenant
2
โ˜•๏ธ
The moment I hear that we are being used to drive a better deal at renewal with their current solution, I'm out. Not going to waste a cycle or any more time to help them since they aren't ever going to commit to my platform.
ChickenWings
Opinionated
0
Tom Callahan's Son
Exactly.

I wont work for free to help you get a lower price elsewhere
Diablo
Politicker
1
Sr. AE
How much is he paying and whatโ€™s his ideal price. If itโ€™s a few % I donโ€™t think the other vendor would mind discounting. Things to know - how is the current product solving the problem, how are you different and what special value add your product would bring apart from the right price?
ChickenWings
Opinionated
0
Tom Callahan's Son
The holes exactly.

He was bidding a fairly commoditized solution. His incumbent wasn't failing in support, either. Not really a problem to solve other than price.

Without commitment to move to me, he could simply just use me to get a lower price with his incumbent...no change, no work, just a lower price.
7

Manager

Advice
13
11

CEO as your Sales Manager?

Question
10
14
Members only

Finance

Question
30
Would you honestly consider making a move to financial services (sales, not research)?
44% "If the price is right she'll dance all night." -Thomas Jefferson
45% No, I like Saas/etc too much.
12% I would consider the change, but have lots of questions.
103 people voted